PLEASE let Jason go home on AI tonight!!

[JustMoi]

That boy sounds the SAME no matter what he sings. I can't stand him!!! It's bad enough that Carly went home last week instead of him. Don't compound it by letting him stay longer!

[JustMoi]

Well, shit. He's safe. It's pointless to continue. The American public has no IDEA what they are doing.

[haleysmom]

Well I like him.... but don't blame me... I didn't vote "thcatfight"

[babymakes4]

At this point I don't think it matters what order they all go home in, as long as the right person wins

[MomX3]

love him!

[SunnySouth]

Yeah idc I just want David Cook to win! I do vote.

[HammBugga]

I agree with BM4. heh. Who went home anyways?

[nikkifaith]

Carly Simon.

[Meredith]

Brooke?!?!

[HammBugga]

Carly Simon.


That was last week. Who went home this week?

[Meredith]

Carly Smithson is the AI contestant that went home. Carly Simon is the folky singer/songwriter that Brooke resembles in her song style. I'm wondering if that's what Nikki meant.

[nikkifaith]

Yes, Meredith. That is what my mom calls her. :D

[HammBugga]

oh yeah, lol.

[QuiltyConscience]

She does remind me of Carly Simon. I like her.

[Meredith]

Yeah, I always had a soft spot for her. I will say, though, that I thought her version of "I'm a Believer" sucked beans. I thought her second song was good, though.

[StElmosFire]

Yeah, I always had a soft spot for her. I will say, though, that I thought her version of "I'm a Believer" sucked beans. I thought her second song was good, though.

It did suck. For some reason when I hear that song I envision Donkey on Shrek cutting up a rug singing that song :lol:

[JustMoi]

I was pissed when they voted Carly off last week. She DID have the best vocal skills, even if her song choice sucked on occasion.

Jason just pisses me off at this point because he could sing ANYTHING and it would still sound the same.